If sometimes wrecking balls and explosive mines are greeted with relief by those who perceive in a specific built work a disfigurement to urban decorum or human dignity (just think of the vituperated Vele in Scampia), it also happens that the destruction of an architecture takes place with deep regret beyond the Kantian aesthetic judgement of the “beautiful” or other subjectivistic evaluative parameters. This is the case of architectures of the past that interpreted the spirit of an era and of those who designed them, that no longer exist today but continue to survive in photographs of the past, architecture books or in the minds of those who lived them. Thus, we cite in everlasting memory works that have disappeared in their built forms but are timeless and crucial in the history of architectural thought: overwhelmed by catastrophic events (Crystal Palace by Joseph Paxton, World Trade Center by Minoru Yamasaki) or temporary (Esprit Nouveau Pavilion by Le Corbusier); overwhelmed by decay (Frank Lloyd Wright’s Imperial Hotel, Minoru Yamasaki’s Pruitt-Igoe, Alison & Peter Smithson’s Robin Hood Gardens, Kisho Kurokawa’s Nakagin Capsule Tower Building) or by the natural process of evolution of urban systems (Ernest Flag's Singer Building, McKim,Mead&White’s Pensylvania Station, Bertrand Goldberg’s Prentice Women’s Hospital and Maternity Center, OMA’s Netherlands Dance Theater); or, erased by the hand of man who has not seized their representative and testimonial value (Victor Horta’s La Maison du Peuple; Richard Neutra’s Gettyburg Cyclorama; Angelo Bianchetti’s Autogrill Pavesi in Montepulciano; Miguel Fisac’s Laboratorios Jorba). If it is certain that nothing is created and nothing is destroyed but everything is transformed, even without indulging in a nostalgic cult of the past, the (rhetorical) question that arises spontaneously is whether, in some cases, the void that some of these works have left is not above all cultural and whether, in others, the replacement has compensated for the loss.
15 architectural icons that no longer exist
Even masterworks got lost: we remember the ones that remain, in the history of architecture, crucial testimonies to the era and the thinking of those who designed them.
Photo by Philippe Henry Delamotte on wikimedia commons
Photo on wikimediacommons
Photo on wikimedia commons
Photo by Jack E. Boucher on wikidata
Photo on wikimedia commons
Photo on wikimedia commons
Photo on wikimedia commons
Photo by Roger W on CreativeCommons
Photo on wikimedia commons
Photo United States Geological Survey – United States Geological Survey from Wikipedia
Photo by Acroterion on wikimedia commons
Photo by Jack Boucher on wikimedia commons
Photo on wikimedia commons
Photo on wikimedia commons
Photo by Scarletgreen on CreativeCommons
Photo by Ncole458 on CreativeCommons
Photo by Stevecadman on wikimedia commons
Photo by Stephen Richards on wikimedia commons
Photo by Umbugbene on wikipedia
Photo by pingnews.com on CreativeCommons
Photo by Rory Hyde on Flickr
Photo by Ralf Roletschek (talk) on wikipedia
View Article details
- Chiara Testoni
- 21 February 2024
Built as part of the 1851 London World's Exhibition to highlight the qualities of emerging technologies in glass and steel, the Pavilion was originally installed in Hyde Park, before being moved to another part of the town. Destroyed by fire in 1936, it inspired many other buildings that made lightness and transparency a plus in spite of the bulky architecture of the past.
The Art Nouveau complex, commissioned by the Belgian Workers’ Party, was distributed over four floors in an irregular plot and was characterised by maximum functionality and ornamental sobriety (unlike other Horta's achievements). The building was demolished in 1965 and replaced by a skyscraper, not without controversy at what was considered an architectural crime.
The 187m, 47-storey building that housed the headquarters of the Singer Manufacturing Company, a famous sewing machine manufacturer, was in the years following its construction the tallest building in the world and a strongly recognised landmark in Manhattan. Community efforts to have it recognised as a historical landmark were useless: it was demolished in the late 1960s and replaced by the current One Liberty Plaza.
The Beaux Arts style building, originally a hub in early 20th century New York and a community landmark, was demolished in 1963 due to declining rail transit flows. In its place there is Madison Square Garden and the current version of Penn Station.
The complex was designed by the master of organic architecture, here still influenced by the Mayan revivalism that he was also experimenting with in the same years in Ennis House in Los Angeles. Having survived earthquakes, the timeworn building was demolished in 1963 to make way for the third version of the hotel.
The Pavilion, conceived for the 1925 International Exhibition of Decorative Arts in Paris, was a full-scale prototype of a standardised dwelling composed of mass-produced elements, which aimed to promote the benefits of efficient and inexpensive technologies to meet housing demand and the need for quality housing in cities. It was widely opposed by the organisers of the event who tried to conceal it because of the disruptive, revolutionary message and explicit disavowal of Art Deco that the Expo represented. Decades after it was dismantled, a faithful copy was reconstructed in 1977 in Bologna, which now houses an exhibition venue.
The large social housing project was conceived to meet the city's pressing housing need in the post-war years. In the period immediately following its construction, living conditions in the complex slowly began to decline into deep socio-economic and environmental degradation. The demolition of the 33 mammoth buildings took place between 1972 and 1974 and was accompanied by an intense debate on public social housing policies that regarded the housing complex as an obvious symbol of national failure. The demolition of the Pruitt-Igoe was one of the first demolitions of modern architectural buildings and was described by architectural theorist and historian Charles Jencks as "the day modern architecture died".
Designed by one of the pioneers of Californian modernism, the visitor centre at the site of the Battle of Pickett's Charge during the American Civil War in 1863 housed an 1883 cyclorama by Paul Philippoteaux and an observation deck. Due to high maintenance and restoration costs, the building was demolished despite public protests and the fact that it was considered a site of outstanding historical and architectural importance.
In the era of the economic boom in which Italy looked to the future with optimism and freedom sped by on four wheels, in the footsteps of the American way of life, the Pavesi bridge-type autogrill between the Bettolle-Valdichiana and Chiusi-ChiancianoTerme tollbooths was a point of reference for tourists, holidaymakers and commuters who savoured a moment of relaxation here. Autostrade per l’Italia is replacing it with two turrets, more functional, less poetic. A memory of a somewhat naive and happily dreamy past that is unlikely to return
The building on the outskirts of Madrid was an example of the balance between lightness and materiality: the articulation of the floors, staggered 45 degrees apart, suggested the image of an Asian temple (the building was commonly referred to as 'the Pagoda') while the virtuosic use of rough concrete with traces of wooden formwork winked at Brutalism. Not recognised as a historical asset to be protected, it was demolished in 1999 to make way for a new tertiary building.
This mixed-use (residential and tertiary) complex is considered one of the most representative examples of the Japanese Metabolist movement, which saw the city and society as living organisms in continuous growth and transformation, to whose needs only technology could provide concrete answers. The intervention consisted of two interconnected towers containing 140 prefabricated, independent capsules, each replaceable every 25 years. Severely degraded over the years, it was demolished due to the high costs for its renovation.
The mammoth precast concrete complex consisted of two buildings (10 and 7 storeys, totalling 213 flats). Conceived as a manifesto of progressive social housing in opposition to the rigidity of the Modern Movement, the Smithsons' project developed the theme of collective housing in close connection with that of public space (from the vast central open space to the distributive paths at height) as an essential hub of community life and sociability. Although authoritative voices were raised to prevent its dismantling due to its advanced state of decay, the work was demolished: on the occasion of the 16th International Architecture Exhibition, the Victoria and Albert Museum in London exhibited a fragment of a façade of the complex in the Pavilion of Applied Arts.
The Brutalist complex was characterised by a 9-storey concrete quatrefoil tower with oval windows, cantilevered over a 5-storey rectangular body. Used as a maternity centre, with medical stations in the central core and patient wards in the four lobes, the complex curvilinear structure entered building history through the use of early computer-aided design techniques. The building was razed in 2013 when the owners, Northwestern University, needed to locate new medical research facilities in the area.
At 417m and 415m high, the twin towers were the tallest buildings in the world when they opened. The complex, built with the aim of revitalising Lower Manhattan, was inspired by the 1939 New York World's Fair exhibition, called the World Trade Center, based on an idea of global peace pursued through trade (a vision difficult to realise and drastically disregarded by history). The story of their destruction, due to the terrorist attack of 11 September 2001, is sadly well known.
The complex in the centre of The Hague, in a rapidly changing area, housed not only the dance theatre designed by OMA, but also a concert hall and a hotel by other designers. The theatre was divided into three parallel programmatic zones: the stage area and the 1,001-seat auditorium; the central area with the rehearsal studios; the area of the offices, dressing rooms and dancers' common rooms. The theatre had a structure of steel beams and girders, using metal cladding with sheet rock covered with stucco, marble and gold foil. The roof had a self-supporting structure of a double layer of trapezoid folded sheet steel.